I've never ordered from Shutterfly before but I'm very tempted after browsing through all of their cards. Here are a few of my favorites:
I would love to put a photo of our first kiss as a married couple in the frame.
Being the lover of all things Scottish and tartan, I think this is my top pick for a current card.
I like this one- maybe to send as a new year's card for next year to recap the first year of our married life!
Shutterfly also has some cute gift tags you might want to look into. This one is my favorite:
Note: I received a promo code for 50 cards in return for a post on my favorites! Check it out: http://bit.ly/sfly2010